Linux为啥查某个进程的线程，查出来的所有线程的pid不一样啊

Posted 2020-08-11

• 楼上说的linux线程和进程是一样的，这个说法是错误的。

• 看了楼主的问题，感觉楼主是被PID给弄混了，线程进程都会有自己的ID，这个ID就叫做PID，PID是不特指进程ID，线程ID也可以叫做PID。

引用原文

The four threads will have the same PID but only when viewed from above. What you (as a user) call a PID is not what the kernel (looking from below) calls a PID.

In the kernel, each thread has it‘s own ID, called a PID (although it would possibly make more sense to call this a TID, or thread ID) and they also have a TGID (thread group ID) which is the PID of the thread that started the whole process.

Simplistically, when a new process is created, it appears as a thread where both the PID and TGID are the same (new) number.

When a thread starts another thread, that started thread gets its own PID (so the scheduler can schedule it independently) but it inherits the TGID from the original thread.

That way, the kernel can happily schedule threads independent of what process they belong to, while processes (thread group IDs) are reported to you.

关于线程继承关系图如下：

               USER VIEW
 <-- PID 43 --> <----------------- PID 42 ----------------->
                     +---------+
                     | process |
                    _| pid=42  |_
                  _/ | tgid=42 | \_ (new thread) _
       _ (fork) _/   +---------+                        /                                        +---------+
+---------+                                    | process |
| process |                                    | pid=44  |
| pid=43  |                                    | tgid=42 |
| tgid=43 |                                    +---------+
+---------+
 <-- PID 43 --> <--------- PID 42 --------> <--- PID 44 --->
                     KERNEL VIEW

在这里你可以清晰的看到，创建一个新的进程会给一个新的PID和TGID，并且2个值相同，当创建一个新的线程的时候，会给你一个新的PID，并且TGID和之前开始的进程一致。

• 楼主按下H，切换到进程视图，会发现只剩下一个了

建议建议楼主不要被名字PID给迷惑，一个东西在不同视角是不一样的。

建议楼主用HTOP，清晰方便，高效，还带命令行显示图。

另外附上

Linux通过进程查看线程的方法 1).htop按t(显示进程线程嵌套关系)和H(显示线程) ，然后F4过滤进程名。2).ps -eLf | grep java(快照，带线程命令，e是显示全部进程，L是显示线程，f全格式输出) 3).pstree -p <pid>(显示进程树，不加pid显示所有) 4).top -Hp <pid> (实时) 5).ps -T -p <pid>(快照) 推荐程度按数字从小到大。

希望能被采纳！

 

参考资料：

https://segmentfault.com/q/1010000003586656